Emailing an AC or PC

Emailing an AC or PC

Your paper can get accepted by emailing an AC or PC, but only if the reviewer breaks the rules.

ICLR 2022: a reviewer said our paper wasn't novel because of a paper posted on arXiv 3.5 months before the deadline. They cited a "30-day rule." The real window was 4 months, and arXiv-only papers don't count anyway.

We asked the PCs. They corrected the reviewer on our forum the next day -> Paper accepted!

Another time, we had a review that was about a completely different paper. We emailed the PCs. Reject → accept, the next day.

The problems we raised were factual, and a chair was able to check it in 60 seconds.

If a reviewer doesn't like your paper or doesn't understand your paper, do not write to the ACs/PCs. It's your job to write your paper so good they can't ignore you (h/t Steve Martin), and to find a venue which appreciates it. That's hard and it might take a few tries.

I'll try to post a few more tips before ICLR discussion closes Nov 18.

First posted on LinkedIn, November 9, 2026.