Emailing an AC or PC

Your paper can get accepted by emailing an AC or PC, but only if the reviewer breaks the rules.
ICLR 2022: a reviewer said our paper wasn't novel because of a paper posted on arXiv 3.5 months before the deadline. They cited a "30-day rule." The real window was 4 months, and arXiv-only papers don't count anyway.
We asked the PCs. They corrected the reviewer on our forum the next day -> Paper accepted!
Another time, we had a review that was about a completely different paper. We emailed the PCs. Reject → accept, the next day.
The problems we raised were factual, and a chair was able to check it in 60 seconds.
If a reviewer doesn't like your paper or doesn't understand your paper, do not write to the ACs/PCs. It's your job to write your paper so good they can't ignore you (h/t Steve Martin), and to find a venue which appreciates it. That's hard and it might take a few tries.
I'll try to post a few more tips before ICLR discussion closes Nov 18.
First posted on LinkedIn, November 9, 2026.


